404//MEANINGSSYS.ONLINE

Philosophy

Nihilism

was nietzsche a nihilist

NY-uh-liz-um/ˈnaɪ(h)ɪlɪzəm/
DEAFENINGSILENCEOPPOSITES, FUSED

Nihilism is the position that some whole domain we take seriously — morality, knowledge, or meaning — has no real foundation at all.

No single coiner. The word is in German print before Jacobi - Obereit in 1787 and Jenisch in 1796 - but its philosophical career starts with Jacobi's open letter to Fichte in 1799, and Turgenev's Fathers and Sons (1862) carried it to a wide readership.

// Where it sits

Nihilism
Foundations holdFoundations are absent

Almost always applied by someone else. Very few people have ever called themselves this.

What it really means

Nihilism has almost never been a thing people call themselves. It started as an insult and has mostly stayed one.

Friedrich Jacobi threw it at transcendental idealism in 1799, in an open letter to Fichte — an accusation aimed at another philosopher. It reached a wide readership through Turgenev's Fathers and Sons in 1862, where it labels the brusque scientific creed of Bazarov, a character who was also not a self-portrait. The word arrives in the world pointed at someone.

Which makes the Nietzsche misattribution particularly odd, since he is the person most often described as one. He treated nihilism as a diagnosis: an oncoming European catastrophe. His argument was that once belief in the Christian God had become unbelievable, everything built on that foundation — including the whole of European morality — was going to collapse, and that the result would be disorientation rather than liberation. His own project, the revaluation of values, is offered as the cure. Values are human creations serving life; therefore better ones can be made.

One more correction. Nihilism now suggests a shrug — apathy, checking out. In the usage that made it famous it was active and destructive: a wholesale refusal of values handed down from outside — Nietzsche's version, in his words, is one where “one actually puts one's shoulder to the plough; one destroys”. The passive version exists, and he distinguishes it, but it isn't the original. Nihilism was a demolition project, not a mood.

Where it comes from

nihilLatin — nothing, from ne- 'not' + hīlum 'a trifle'
-ismGreek-derived suffix forming names of doctrines

The -ism does the damage: it converts a negation into what sounds like a creed with adherents, which is exactly how the word has been misused since Jacobi.

1799Friedrich Jacobi uses the word in his open letter to Fichte to negatively characterise transcendental idealism - as an accusation, not a self-description. Earlier German uses are on record for Obereit (1787) and Jenisch (1796).
1862The term reaches a wide readership through Turgenev's Fathers and Sons, where it labels the brusque scientific creed of the character Bazarov.

Myths & misconceptions

Myth

Nihilism was Nietzsche's philosophy.

Reality

He diagnosed it as an oncoming European catastrophe, not a position he held. His claim was that once belief in the Christian God becomes unbelievable, everything built on it — including the whole of European morality — faces collapse. His own project, the revaluation of values, is the proposed cure: values are human creations, so better ones can be made.

Myth

Nihilism means shrugging, not caring, checking out.

Reality

In the usage that made the word famous it named an active, destructive programme — Turgenev's Bazarov, and Nietzsche's characterisation of nihilism as a wholesale refusal of values handed down from outside, where in his words 'one actually puts one's shoulder to the plough; one destroys'. Passive drift is a distinct and weaker case, and Nietzsche separates the two.

Compare & contrast

Nihilism vs absurdism

Frequently merged, explicitly opposed. Camus built absurdism specifically by rejecting nihilism — the absurd for him leads to action and participation, where nihilism concludes that no action is warranted. Treating them as synonyms erases the distinction Camus spent a book making.

//NihilismAbsurdism
ConcludesNothing warrants actionAct anyway, lucidly
Toward othersNo obligationSolidarity
CamusRejected itWrote it
Named byEnemiesLater shorthand

How it connects

  • Absurdismthe position built explicitly against this one.
  • Existentialismstarts from the same premise and draws the opposite conclusion.

Tell it apart

Questions people ask

Was Nietzsche a nihilist?
No — he treated nihilism as the crisis to be survived. His view was that once belief in the Christian God becomes unbelievable, the whole structure resting on it faces collapse, producing disorientation rather than liberation. His answer was a 'revaluation of values': since values are human creations serving life, new ones can be built.
Who invented the word nihilism?
There's no clean single coiner. Friedrich Jacobi used it in 1799, in an open letter to Fichte, to negatively characterise transcendental idealism, and it became popular after appearing in Turgenev's Fathers and Sons in 1862. In both cases it started as an accusation aimed at someone else — which is most of the word's history.
What are the types of nihilism?
Moral or ethical nihilism (there are no absolute moral values), epistemological nihilism (knowledge and truth are unattainable), and existential nihilism (life has no intrinsic meaning). They're independent — you can hold one and reject the others, which is why 'nihilist' used as a single label usually obscures more than it says.

Sources