Where it sits
The difference is resemblance, and resemblance is what turns nesting into commentary.
Tell it apart
| Aspect | Mise en abyme | Frame narrative |
|---|---|---|
| Requires resemblance | Yes | No |
| Is a comment on the whole | Yes | Not necessarily |
| Origin | Heraldry | Ancient storytelling |
| Depth | Potentially infinite | Usually two levels |
A frame narrative simply nests one story inside another. Mise en abyme requires resemblance — the inner work must mirror the outer one. Nesting is structural; mise en abyme is a comment.
What it doesn't mean
A story within a story is a FRAME NARRATIVE. Mise en abyme requires the inner work to be a REDUCED MODEL OF THE OUTER ONE — reflecting its structure, themes or situation. Two nested stories with nothing in common are not mise en abyme.
It is originally HERALDIC. 'En abyme' names the centre point of a shield, and a shield bearing a smaller shield there is the source image. Gide borrowed the coat-of-arms vocabulary in 1893.
What it really means
The term comes from coats of arms.
In heraldry, en abyme names the centre point of a shield — abyme being an archaic spelling of abîme, abyss. And a shield that bears, at that centre, a smaller shield is described as being en abyme. When that inner shield repeats the outer one, the design contains its own portrait, which in principle contains its own portrait, which in principle contains its own.
André Gide borrowed that vocabulary for literature in an 1893 journal entry, and the borrowing is exact: a work containing a reduced model of itself.
The distinction people miss is the one that makes the term worth having. A story within a story is not mise en abyme. That is a frame narrative — nesting, and as old as storytelling. Mise en abyme requires the inner work to resemble the outer one: to mirror its structure, its situation, its themes, its problem.
A play performed inside a play, which restages the crime the outer play is about. A painting hanging in a room that shows that room. A novel whose protagonist is writing a novel that is going badly in exactly the way this one is.
So nesting is structural. Mise en abyme is commentary — the work turning briefly to look at itself, and letting you see it do so.
What it produces in a reader is a very specific and slightly uncomfortable effect: you stop being inside the work and become aware of the work as a made thing. Which is the opposite of immersion, and is why it is used sparingly. A story that reflects itself has admitted, mid-sentence, that it is a story.
And the heraldic image carries one implication the literary term keeps. The abyss in abyme is not decoration. A shield containing itself containing itself does not stop — it recedes, at full speed, into a point. The device is named for the direction it points, which is down, and forever.
Where it comes from
French — placed in
the heraldic term for the centre point of a shield — an archaic spelling of abîme, 'abyss'
In heraldry, a shield bearing a smaller shield at its centre is 'en abyme'. The literary sense borrows a technical term from coats of arms.
- heraldry
'En abyme' names the centre point of a shield; a shield bearing a smaller shield there is the source image.
- 1893
André Gide adopts the heraldic term in a journal entry, applying it to works that contain a reduced model of themselves.
In real life
- In Shakespeare's Hamlet, Hamlet has the visiting players stage The Murder of Gonzago, renamed The Mousetrap: a king poisoned by a relative who then wins the queen. It is a small model of the very crime the larger play is about, staged in front of the murderer.
- In André Gide's The Counterfeiters (1925), the novelist Édouard is writing a novel called The Counterfeiters. Gide, who brought the term into criticism, built his own book around one.
- Jan van Eyck's Arnolfini Portrait (1434): a convex mirror on the back wall reflects the room, the couple from behind and two figures standing in the doorway, a tiny second view of the scene inside the scene.
Questions
Q01What does 'abyme' actually mean?
It is the heraldic term for the centre point of a shield — an archaic spelling of abîme, 'abyss'. A shield bearing a smaller shield at its centre is described as 'en abyme'.
Q02How is it different from a story within a story?
A frame narrative just nests. Mise en abyme requires the inner work to be a reduced model of the outer one — mirroring its structure, themes or situation.
Q03Who applied it to literature?
André Gide, in an 1893 journal entry, borrowing the heraldic vocabulary.
Sources
- Mise en abyme — Wikipedia.
- Wiktionary — mise en abyme.
- André Gide — Wikipedia (the 1893 journal entry).