404//MEANINGSSYS.ONLINE

:: COMPARE ::

EnshittificationvsPlanned obsolescence

The short answer

Planned obsolescence degrades a product you own. Enshittification degrades a position you are locked into. The lock-in, not the decay, is the actual mechanism — you stay because leaving costs you your data, your audience or your history.

Side by side

AspectEnshittificationPlanned obsolescence
TargetA platform positionA product
You can leaveTechnicallyYes
Needs two sidesYesNo
Ends inCollapseA new purchase

What each one means

Enshittification

A platform decaying into something worse for everyone on it. Doctorow's model gives three stages: good to users, then abusive to users to please business customers, then abusive to those business customers to claw the value back for the platform itself.

Full definition of Enshittification

Planned obsolescence

The contrast above sets out how Planned obsolescence differs from Enshittification on the points that actually matter.