404//MEANINGSSYS.ONLINE

Literary

Anaphora

what is anaphora

uh-NAF-uh-ruh
BUY LOWSELL HIGH

Repeating the same words at the start of successive clauses — we shall fight, we shall fight, we shall fight. In linguistics the same word names something else: a pronoun or other expression pointing back to something already said.

// Where it sits

Anaphora
Repetition insistsRepetition builds

Which is why a list of three anaphoric clauses feels like an argument and a list of three plain ones feels like a list.

What it really means

Repetition on its own is insistence. Say a thing three times and you have said it three times.

Anaphora does something different, and the difference is structural rather than emphatic. By repeating the opening of successive clauses, it establishes a frame — and once a listener recognises the frame, usually by the second instance, everything that follows is heard as a variation within a structure rather than as a fresh assertion.

Which is why anaphora builds and plain repetition merely accumulates. The audience stops evaluating each clause independently and starts anticipating the next one. They are no longer being told things; they are following a pattern, and following is closer to agreeing than listening is.

The Greek is ana- + pherein: a carrying back.

The device has a mirror. Epistrophe repeats at the end of successive clauses instead — and the effect inverts. Anaphora sets up; epistrophe lands. One creates expectation, the other satisfies it. Using both at once has its own name: symploce.

One warning worth having, because it produces genuine confusion between disciplines. Linguistics uses this word for something else entirely. There, anaphora is the relationship by which an expression — usually a pronoun — refers back to an earlier antecedent: the she in Maria said she would come. That is not a rhetorical figure, has nothing to do with repetition, and shares only the Greek root.

So a sentence can be thick with anaphora in the linguistic sense — nearly every sentence anyone writes is — and carry none of the rhetorical kind, because having the one tells you nothing whatever about having the other. Two fields inherited the same word from the same language and gave it two unrelated jobs, and neither has shown any interest in giving it up.

Where it comes from

ana-Greek — back, again
phereinGreek — to carry

Literally 'a carrying back'. The same Greek word names a different concept in modern linguistics — a pronoun pointing back to an earlier noun — and that root is all the two senses share.

antiquityClassical rhetoric catalogues anaphora among the figures of repetition.
2nd century CEThe Greek grammarian Apollonius Dyscolus already uses anaphorá for a different phenomenon — the way a pronoun refers back to an earlier antecedent. Modern linguistics inherited the term from that tradition.

Myths & misconceptions

Myth

Anaphora means one thing.

Reality

It means two, in two fields. In RHETORIC it is repetition at the start of successive clauses. In LINGUISTICS it is the relationship by which an expression — usually a pronoun — refers back to an antecedent, as 'she' does in 'Maria said she would come'. The two senses have nothing to do with each other beyond the Greek root.

Myth

It's just repetition for emphasis.

Reality

It does something structural that plain repetition doesn't. Repeating the OPENING creates a fixed frame, so each clause is heard as a variation on the same theme rather than as a new statement — which is why it builds rather than merely insists.

Compare & contrast

Anaphora vs epistrophe

Anaphora repeats at the START of successive clauses; epistrophe repeats at the END. Same technique, opposite end of the line — and they feel completely different, because one sets an expectation and the other satisfies one.

//AnaphoraEpistrophe
Repetition atThe startThe end
EffectBuildsLands
Sets upExpectationResolution
Both togetherSymploceSymploce

How it connects

  • Chiasmusthe other structural figure built on arrangement rather than meaning.
  • Asyndetonthe other device that changes rhythm by changing structure.

Tell it apart

Questions people ask

What's the difference from epistrophe?
Anaphora repeats at the beginning of successive clauses; epistrophe repeats at the end. Using both at once is called symploce.
Why is it used in speeches?
Because repeating the opening words emphasises the idea, adds rhythm, and makes the line easier to remember, and it binds the separate statements into one series rather than a list of unrelated claims. Martin Luther King Jr. repeats 'I have a dream' eight times in the 1963 speech for exactly that effect.
What does it mean in linguistics?
Something entirely different: the relationship by which a pronoun refers back to an earlier antecedent. Two fields, one Greek root, no shared meaning.

Sources