Glossary · term explained

What is metaphysics?

Metaphysics is the study of what is fundamentally real. Not what the world contains — that is science's job — but what it is for something to exist at all, what time and causation are, and what makes a thing the same thing over time. The name is an accident of ancient cataloguing, and the subject is older than its label.

Metaphysics is the branch of philosophy concerned with the fundamental nature of reality: what exists, what kinds of things there are, and the nature of existence, time, causation, identity, possibility and necessity. It addresses questions that empirical investigation presupposes rather than settles.

The positions · at a glance
The term at a glance
Position 01

The study of reality

What it covers

Existence, time, causation, identity, possibility, and the fundamental categories of what there is.

Position 02

An accidental name

Where the word came from

From the ancient arrangement of Aristotle's works — the books placed after (meta) the Physics. It was never a claim about the beyond.

Position 03

Beneath science

How it differs

Science asks what causes what; metaphysics asks what causation is. It examines what empirical enquiry assumes rather than tests.

Position 04

Persistently attacked

The standing objection

Logical positivists dismissed it as meaningless; Kant restricted it to appearances. It has outlived both critiques.

The name is a filing accident. When Aristotle's works were catalogued, the books dealing with being and first causes were placed after those on physics, and got labelled ta meta ta physika — the ones after the Physics. The word has since acquired connotations of the supernatural that have nothing to do with the subject, which concerns the structure of reality, not spirits.

The clearest way to locate metaphysics is by what it asks relative to science. A physicist investigates which events cause which. A metaphysician asks what causation is — whether it is a real relation in the world or a pattern we impose, whether causes necessitate their effects or merely make them probable. Science establishes that objects persist; metaphysics asks what persistence consists in, given that the matter is constantly replaced. These questions are presupposed by empirical work rather than settled by it.

Science asks what causes what. Metaphysics asks what causation is.The dividing line

Its central topics recur throughout philosophy. Ontology, the study of what exists, asks whether numbers, properties and possibilities are real things or useful fictions. Time raises whether past and future exist or only the present, and whether time's passage is real or a feature of how we experience it. Identity asks what makes something the same thing across change — the ship of Theseus problem, and its personal version. Modality concerns possibility and necessity: what does it mean to say something could have been otherwise?

The subject has been declared dead more than once. Hume proposed consigning metaphysical works to the flames as containing nothing but sophistry. Kant argued that reason inevitably generates metaphysical questions it cannot answer, and restricted legitimate knowledge to appearances. The logical positivists held that metaphysical statements are literally meaningless, since no observation could verify them — an argument that famously failed its own test, since the verification principle is not itself verifiable. Metaphysics survived all three, partly because the questions reassert themselves the moment anyone tries to say precisely what a scientific theory is claiming.

People also askQuick answers

What is metaphysics?

The branch of philosophy concerned with the fundamental nature of reality — existence, time, causation, identity, possibility and necessity. It asks what the world is like at its most basic level.

Why is it called metaphysics?

From the ancient cataloguing of Aristotle's works: the books on being and first causes were placed after those on physics, and were labelled 'the ones after the Physics.' The name was never a claim about the supernatural.

What is the difference between metaphysics and science?

Science investigates what causes what; metaphysics asks what causation is. It examines the assumptions empirical enquiry relies on — the nature of objects, time, and identity — rather than testing hypotheses about them.

Is metaphysics meaningless?

The logical positivists argued so, holding that unverifiable statements are meaningless. The argument undermined itself, since the verification principle isn't verifiable either. Metaphysics remains a mainstream area of philosophy.

Sources & further reading

A summary following standard scholarly accounts. Usage of this term varies between traditions and periods.