404//MEANINGSSYS.ONLINE

Work

Flywheel

what is a flywheel in business

FLY-weel

A heavy rotating wheel that stores energy and holds a machine at a steady speed. In business it is the borrowed image: a system where each turn makes the next turn easier, so momentum compounds and no single push explains the breakthrough.

Jim Collins developed the business 'flywheel effect' in Good to Great, 16 October 2001. He did not coin the word — flywheel is an old mechanical term for a momentum-storing wheel.

// Where it sits

The flywheel claim
One decisive moveTen thousand small ones

Which is unsatisfying, unquotable, and probably why the metaphor gets used for the opposite purpose.

What it really means

Jim Collins described the object with unusual specificity: a wheel of about 5,000 pounds, 30 feet in diameter, 2 feet thick, mounted on an axle.

Push it. Almost nothing happens. Push again. It moves an inch. Keep pushing — for hours — and it completes a turn, then two, then ten, and then at some point it is turning so fast that stopping it is the hard problem.

The argument he built on it, in Good to Great (16 October 2001), is genuinely counter-intuitive and it is the part that gets dropped: no single heaveno matter how large — accounts for more than a small fraction of the cumulative effect. Transformations that look revolutionary from outside were gradual from inside. People inside those companies, asked afterwards which decision was the turning point, frequently could not identify one, because there wasn't one.

His name for the opposite pattern is the better half of the idea. The doom loop: push the flywheel one way, stop, reconsider, change direction, push again. Every individual push is energetic and defensible. Nothing accumulates, because the accumulation was never in any single push — it was in all of them pointing the same way.

Which makes the flywheel a metaphor about direction and repetition, not about effort. And it is routinely used to mean the opposite: our flywheel has become corporate shorthand for a diagram of virtuous circles, which is roughly the inverse of an argument about the invisibility of causes.

One piece of honesty the metaphor's popularity has outrun. The economist Steven D. Levitt noted that two of the eleven companies selected as 'great' later got into serious trouble, that only one dramatically outperformed the market, and that investing in all eleven in 2001 would have underperformed the S&P 500.

The mechanism may well be sound. The evidence base for it was a portfolio that lost to the index.

This page explains the terms and is not investment advice.

Where it comes from

flywheela heavy rotating disk that stores rotational energy

Collins specifies the object precisely — a 5,000-pound wheel, 30 feet in diameter and 2 feet thick. The specificity is the argument: it is enormously hard to start and enormously hard to stop.

16 October 2001Good to Great is published, setting out the flywheel and its opposite, the doom loop.
28 July 2008The economist Steven D. Levitt publishes prominent criticism of the book's company selection.

Myths & misconceptions

Myth

Great companies break through with one decisive move.

Reality

Collins's argument is the opposite: no single heave, however large, reflects more than a small fraction of the cumulative effect on the flywheel. Transformations that look revolutionary from outside were gradual from inside — and the outside can never see which push was the important one, because none of them was.

Myth

The flywheel companies proved the theory.

Reality

Steven D. Levitt noted that two of the selected 'great' companies later got into serious trouble, that only one dramatically outperformed the market, and that investing in all eleven companies in 2001 would have UNDERPERFORMED the S&P 500.

Compare & contrast

Flywheel vs burn rate

The flywheel compounds momentum generated from within. Burn rate consumes momentum purchased from outside. Opposite engines — and only one of them has a date attached.

//FlywheelBurn rate
Momentum fromInsideOutside
Has a deadlineNoYes
Early stageVery slowVery fast
Failure modeNever startsRuns out

How it connects

  • Network Effectone specific mechanism a flywheel can be built on.
  • Burn Ratethe opposite engine, running on someone else's fuel.

Tell it apart

Questions people ask

Where does the flywheel come from?
Jim Collins's Good to Great, published 16 October 2001.
What's the doom loop?
The comparison companies' pattern — pushing the flywheel one way, stopping, changing direction, and never accumulating momentum in any of them.
Has the book been criticised?
Yes. Steven D. Levitt noted that two of the eleven selected companies got into serious trouble, that only one dramatically beat the market, and that the eleven-company portfolio would have underperformed the S&P 500. This page explains the terms and is not investment advice.

Sources